WWE gab in der Pre-Show zu NXT TakeOver: Phoenix und auf WWE.com die Gewinner der NXT Year-End Awards bekannt:
Overall Competitor of the Year:
Kairi Sane
Rivalry of the Year:
Johnny Gargano vs. Tommaso Ciampa
Male Competitor of the Year:
Tommaso Ciampa
Breakout Star of the Year:
Ricochet
Female Competitor of the Year:
Kairi Sane
Match of the Year:
Andrade vs. Johnny Gargano – NXT Championship Match (TakeOver: Philadelphia)
Tag Team of the Year:
The Undisputed ERA
Future Star of NXT:
Io Shirai
TakeOver of the Year:
NXT TakeOver: New Orleans